The decade of the 1930s became an outstanding time of growth and popularity for American rugby, albeit in the narrow geographical corridor from Boston to Princeton, New Jersey. In 1930/31, two clubs developed in New York City, the NYRFC and the French RFC, composed of French immigrants working in the restaurant trade. Three new clubs in those years started at Harvard, Yale, and Princeton. Although, from the outset, expatriates comprised the largest part of these rugby memberships, over time, more Americans joined, becoming enthusiastic participants in the sport.
The emerging group founded the Eastern Rugby Union in 1934. In a few years, as many as twelve teams played in a competitive ERU league. The lineup of members:
The ERU lineup
City (6): NYRFC, French, Pilgrims, St. Andrews (NJ), Queens, Boston RFC (1935)
College (6): Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Cornell, Hofstra, Long Island U.
Cambridge Tours
Three different tours arrived from Cambridge, in 1933, 1934, and 1938.
1933: The Cambridge Vandals
The Cambridge Vandals, primarily, a cricket team, toured Canada in the late summer of 1933, also playing some rugby and ending in Chicago. The team wanted to visit New York City, which had no cricket team. It contacted the NYRFC, offering to play rugby if New York would guarantee a $500 match fee to pay for the added travel and hotel expenses. The English team featured three rugby internationals.
The NYRFC agreed, its members raising the finances. Since it was not the official Cambridge varsity side, it had to use the Vandals name. In opposition, the hosts created an All American Eastern Team from the Big Three, the French RFC, and NYRFC. The contest, the first rugby match played in Gaelic Park, took place on September 9, with 1,000 spectators paying $1.00 admission. The Vandals were victorious 14-11.
1934: Cambridge University XV
The tour to the USA by the official Cambridge University XV represented an innocent but serious breach in the manner in which international tours operated. The tour was arranged by an outside organization without sanctioning from the RFU. The Cambridge XV outplayed opponents with exceptional handling, tactical kicking, and backline speed, attracting crowds and generating wide-ranging press coverage. It won all four matches as follows:
- Cambridge 41 - Harvard 18 - In NYC
- Cambridge 40 - Princeton 10 - In Princeton
- Cambridge 32 - Yale 5 - In New Haven
- Cambridge 23 - All East 9 - In NYC
1938: The Authorized Cambridge Tour
Four years later in April, the ERU succeeded in going through the correct English rugby channels to welcome an authorized Cambridge fifteen to play five matches. The "Light Blue" (as Cambridge was nicknamed) arrived with three internationals. This first-class side had defeated Oxford 8-6 in the 1938 Varsity contest. The ERU actively publicized the event, which included the team's appearance on Lowell Thomas's popular CBS radio show. The Pathé News filmed the final game for its US newsreel. Joseph Kennedy Jr. played center for Harvard and the All-East side. Hopes were high that the American fifteens - certainly, the All East side - would perform at an improved standard from previous Cambridge tours. These expectations were not met:
- Cambridge 40 - Yale 0 (2,000 spectators)
- Cambridge 50 - Harvard 0 (2,500 spectators)
- Cambridge 19 - Princeton 0 (1,000 spectators)
- Cambridge 38 - All New York 6 (2,500 spectators)
- Cambridge 39 - All East 0 (2,000 spectators)
The Times of London wrote despairingly about the mediocre quality of American rugby as experienced on the tour in which Cambridge scored 216 points, conceding only six.
"The (American) backs were too prone to give and take their passes standing still. It was seldom therefore that they developed any sort of combined attack. In a word, they lacked any football sense."
Bermuda
In 1935, the Bermuda Athletic Association invited Harvard and Yale fifteens to visit the island during the colleges' spring vacation. It marked the first American rugby tour to Bermuda, setting the stage for club and college visits in the future. The college men competed against each other and resident Island sides. In subsequent seasons, Princeton and Cornell also sent teams. The hosts offered the "Bermuda Cup" to the winner.
Chicago RFC vs. New York RFC, 1939
During the late 1930s, rugby began in the Midwest, especially with the formation of the Chicago RFC. It found matches against teams in St. Louis, the University of Chicago, the Missouri School of Mines, and the Manitoba All-Stars from Canada. It arranged the first of two matches against the NYRFC on April 30, 1939, the game played at Triborough Stadium, Randalls Island, NYC. The visitors were victorious 13 to 8 to extend an 18-game winning streak.
The return match in the Windy City in November 1939, generated national headlines as it featured the first two Heisman Trophy recipients, Jay Berwanger of the University of Chicago (1935) and Larry Kelley of Yale (1936). Both had turned down playing in the NFL. Chicago triumphed 23-9 to claim the national title. Berwanger was elected to the USA Rugby Hall of Fame in 2016.
After Pearl Harbor, rugby in the east continued briefly into 1942. The ERU would not count ten or more fifteens again until the spring season of 1961.
More from The American Rugby Story
- New Zealand Tour 1905 - Birth of a Legend
- Rugby In France
- USA Olympic Rugby 1920 & 1924
- Rugby Caps and Rugby Balls
- New York RFC 1930 - The USA's First Rugby Club
- Sevens History: Melrose and Middlesex - Part I
- Sevens History: Hong Kong - Part II
- Sevens History: Pace and Rise of Women's Sevens
- More US Rugby Archives