Founded in Manhattan on February 4, 1930 by expatriates from the U.K., Ireland and the Commonwealth, the New York Rugby Football Club was the first urban club in the USA dedicated solely to rugby, and the template for the American city clubs that followed.
The return of rugby to America in 1930 occurred via the formation of the New York Rugby Football Club, the first urban organization in the USA dedicated solely to playing the sport. The founders would be expatriates from the U.K., Ireland, and British Commonwealth countries. They would imbue the new organization with the traditional values of operating an amateur only rugby club. This time-honored British model would become the template for all American city rugby clubs that followed.
A small group of men eager to play the game of their youth again gathered in Manhattan on February 4, 1930, at the offices of James Hunter & Co. on Water Street. The NYRFC elected a full complement of officers, ordered team jerseys in two-colored, alternating horizontal stripes from E.C. Devereux of Eton, England (light blue and dark blue), and designed a club tie. They sent a formal request for an official listing by England's Rugby Football Union, marking America's first entry in the sport's international directory. The third meeting was held at the British Luncheon Club. Thomas Wood, a founder, wrote of the initial recruitment efforts:
"Rugby is an incurable disease. I wrote letters to the sports editors of the NY Times and the NY Herald-Tribune inviting interested parties to contact me if they wanted to play. I ordered a ball from the city's Spalding's store, which had to obtain one from London."
Club Secretary, Albert Woodley, cited the priorities, “The young club needed playing members, non-playing members, opponents, grounds, and just about everything." In the first season of 1930-1931, the country origins of members follow: England 9, Scotland 6, ANZAC 5, USA 3, Ireland 5, South Africa 3, Canada 2. The two most prominent names were George Pfann, Cornell's football All-American and Rhodes Scholar who played rugby for Brasenose College at Oxford, and P.S. De Q. Cabot, capped at scrum half for New Zealand in 1921.
In early April 1930, the club played an initial match against the Philadelphia Marines, a side that learned rugby while stationed in Shanghai, China. The NY Times noted the occasion:
"1,500 Watch Spirited 0-0 Game in Staten Island as Sport is Revived in Met Area."
Eastern Colleges - 1930 & 1931
At the beginning of 1930, the NYRFC could only count on competition from Canadian clubs in Montreal and Québec. In the same year, rugby returned to the college Big Three, Harvard, Princeton, and Yale, in a full revival spurred on by graduate students from the U.K. In addition, U. Penn and Syracuse also mounted fifteens in this period.
Harvard - In March 1930, the Harvard Athletic Association granted the nascent club permission to play matches inside Harvard Stadium. The first contest was a 6-3 loss to Princeton in front of 5,000 spectators. In May of that year, Harvard defeated Syracuse 14-6.
Yale - The Elis' rugby club opened with a win against the U.S. Marines in 1930. The team was composed of British exchange students. The next year, in 1931, the fifteen was singled out for its 15-6 upset against the NYRFC in Manhattan. This second season witnessed the increased participation of American football players.
Princeton - The Tigers were looking for a spring sport and undergraduates created a rugby team. It defeated Harvard and Yale twice in 1931. One student, Harry Langenberg, would start the Missouri Rugby Football Union in 1933. He also was a founder of the St. Louis Ramblers RFC in 1948.
NYRFC Ascendant
The NYRFC became the principal rugby establishment in New York City. Woodley summarized its status, "The NYRFC was RUGBY in those days, because there was nobody else. The club was everything. It did everything." And Manhattan was the media center with eleven daily newspapers, many covering the sport with full column reporting and photos.
The existence of the club enabled expats coming to New York City an opportunity to play rugby. The NYRFC was now listed in the U.K.'s Rugby Union directory with Woodley's contact information. Or, reading the matches in the NY Times, Herald-Tribune, or Journal American, alerted the rugby player to the game's local presence. Within five years, the club grew exponentially, expanded by the stream of seasoned ruggers coming from abroad, and also by the arrival of American college graduates.
The club succeeded in finding Metropolitan venues. At first, it played home games at Thompson Stadium, home to football's semi-pro Staten Island Stapletons. Then it moved to Innisfall Park located at 228th Street and Broadway, The Bronx, which would be renamed Gaelic Park, the official stadium for many years of the Irish Gaelic Football Association. Finally, toward the end of the 1930s, matches were played in the Polo Grounds, Manhattan's stadium of the New York Giants baseball team.
The NYRFC found a club room inside the George Washington Hotel at Lexington and East 23rd Street where members could meet. It flourished after a few start-up years, fielding two fifteens a week. The elected officers operated the club as efficiently as any British-based rugby organization.
The upcoming decade of the 1930s would witness an east coast rugby Renaissance. The NYRFC would assume the leadership position of the Eastern Rugby Union formed in 1934. Ten colleges and clubs competed weekly in the ERU. Fifteens from Cambridge toured on three occasions, generating interest and publicity. In 1939, a Chicago RFC versus the New York RFC two-game contest excited sports fans in the two cities.